by Paul R. Spitzzeri
Amid the ongoing challenges facing Riverside County authorities in arranging for the extradition from Canada of the wanted child murderers, Gordon Stewart Northcott and his mother Louise came the news in the Los Angeles Express of 3 October 1928 that “believing the simple, straight-forward story of 15-year-old Sanford Clark concerning the brutal killing of the ‘headless Mexican boy,'” whose body was found on Hudson Road (now Hacienda Boulevard) just south of Valley Boulevard and at or near the western edge of the Homestead, then owned by Walter P. Temple, the Los Angeles County Grand Jury indicated Gordon for the killing.
The paper added that “the grand jurors, shuddering at the oft-told horror tale which fell from young Clark’s lips, voted unanimously for the indictment under which, if Riverside county fails to convict Northcott, he will be tried here for murder.” A county official completed extradition papers specific to this indictment and these were sent to Sacramento as part of the process followed by Riverside County, which included forwarding to Washington and then Canada’s capital at Ottawa before going to Vancouver, British Columbia for the order to send the Northcotts to California.

Meanwhile, the paper noted that, while the jury heard the gory details from Clark, “Riverside and Los Angeles county officials were jubilant over the discovery of ‘confession letters,'” sent to Cyrus, the father and husband of the wanted pair, were said to “directly connect” the Northcotts and which two Los Angeles Police Department investigators, working with Riverside County Sheriff Clem Sweeters, found them, apparently at the Northcott residence in Los Angeles. These, commented Riverside County District Attorney Albert Ford, would lead to “a perfect hanging case.”
One, from Louise, stated that she recently took out a $5,000 life insurance policy and instructed her spouse, “I want you to use this money and everything else you have in defense of our boy.” Gordon’s missive, explained the Express, “virtually ordered the elder man to force Stanford [sic] Clark . . . ‘to change his story,'” though it was noted that the items were written and mailed before the teen’s sister, Jessie went to authorities with his astounding narrative, while Gordon claimed that he took his mother went to Canada “to keep little mother in ignorance of the charges” leveled by Jessie. It was added that Cyrus, who admitted to knowing of the murders of Walter Collins and the brothers Lewis and Nelson Winslow, “has flatly refused to come to the financial aid of his wife and son.”

A separate short Associated Press report from Vancouver noted that Gordon claimed he had seven attorneys in California at the ready for his defense and told jailhouse guards that he would “block these Riverside dicks [authorities] at every turn of the way.” At the same time, the stress of confinement was clearly weighing heavily as the 21-year-old was quoted as telling the guards, “I will go crazy if they keep me here much longer . . . I am not going back to the states if I can help it.”
With regard to young Collins, the paper also informed readers that the Los Angeles Police Commission, having received a “secret letter” from the county grand jury, voted to hold a hearing concerning charges by his mother Christine that she was forced by police captain Joseph J. Jones to accept a runaway as her missing son, despite her steadfast denials that he was not Walter, and then was committed to the county hospital psychopathic ward for four days and nights. She also accused Jones of offering her money, apparently to keep quiet about what took place. While the commission president said he was unaware of the details, he promised the board would “investigate it to the fullest extent and let the chips fall where they may.”

Los Angeles Times “staff representative James M. Kendrick, in that paper’s number of the 3rd, commented that, while in jail, Gordon and Louise were to be “taken into court once every eight days, until the date of [their] hearing is set,” evidently to make sure that updates on the progress of their cases were provided to a magistrate. A notable point made by the paper was that Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Captain William Bright and county chemist Raymond J. Abernathy asked the Board of Supervisors “to establish a department of criminology as a result of difficulties met in analyzing evidence found in the Northcott case” as it was remarked that “neither city nor county is equipped, authorized or budgeted for such analytical work.”
Showing a photograph of Arthur Hutchins, Jr., the 11-year old who impersonated Walter Collins, hugging his stepmother, who came to Los Angeles from Iowa to retrieve him, the Times observed that the youngster was, following approval from a Superior Court judge, to be released from Juvenile Hall into her custody. Mrs. Hutchins told the press that the youngster ran away from home “because he was under a form of probation” after he was accused of thefts of small amounts of money and police officials made him write a weekly report of his activities. After one of these, he left the town of Marion.

Arthur showed more of the pugnacious attitude that permeated his brief Angel City residence, when an officer told him, “tell your mother how you have almost made a wreck of the police department,” to which the he shot back, “you’ve made a wreck out of me. When asked by his mother if he would be glad to return to Iowa, he rejoined, “when are you going to move out here?” while adding that he would not talk to the children in Marion about his experiences and they he would “let ’em guess for themselves.” As to his impersonation, he turned the matter on Christine, saying “Mrs. Collins said I was her boy, didn’t she? Well, then I wasn’t exactly fooling her.” He allowed that “she was nice to me,” but also proclaimed, “it’s fun to be somebody you aren’t.”
Young Hutchins, however, continued on an errant path for a while as the 1930 census enumerated him as an inmate at the Iowa Training School for Boys, where troubled youth were sent much as with the Whittier State School or the Preston School of Industry in California. He later resided with his late mother’s parents, married at age 27 and had a daughter, worked at various jobs, including for a railroad and as a machinist, and died at age 35 in February 1952.

In its reporting, the Los Angeles Record of the 3rd revealed that a post office inspector discussed the Northcott letters and that the missives were mailed to the Los Angeles house but not received by him because he was already in police custody and “has not been allowed to attend to any personal business or to see any mail.” Moreover, the LAPD officers who were handed the missives turned them over to D.A. Ford “and will probably be used . . . in the forthcoming trial of the asserted slayer and his mother, as corroborative evidence of guilt.”
The paper also noted that Gordon’s letter to Cyrus “directed him to threaten young Clark with imprisonment, ‘or anything,’ to make him change his story of he said he saw and participated in,” while it was inferred that Louise would take her life by mentioning the $5,000 life insurance benefit she wanted for her son’s defense. It also went through some details concerning forensic and other evidence present to the Los Angeles County grand jury, while also observing that, when Gordon was remanded to the Canadian jail for a short period, his arrest warrant was expired and no extradition papers yet received, yet the judge “ordered him held for California authorities.”

In its issue of the 4th, the Express revealed that,
More than 50 boys, ranging in age from 8 to 16 years, have been victims of insane attacks by Gordon Stewart Northcott, master of Wineville’s “murder farm,” according to the story related to the Los Angeles county grand jury by Sanford Clark, 15-year-old nephew of the alleged murderer, it was learned today.
As a result, Detective Lieutenants Ellsworth Hamren and Chester Lloyd, together with Deputy Sheriffs Abe Mendoza and P.P. [José?] Ybarra, began a city and county-wide search for the youths, whose statements will be turned over to Sheriff Clem Sweeters and District Attorney Albert Ford of Riverside county for use during the trial of Northcott and his mother, Mrs. Sarah Louise Northcott, now under arrest in Canada.
The paper additionally noted that investigators Kelley and Quinn contacted the sheriff and D.A. and transmitted a statement “in which the authorities were instructed to prepare to meet an insanity defense by both Northcott and his mother.” This evidently came from an investigation by “youthful members of a ‘club’ said to have been organized by the alleged slayer . . . the purpose of which will be to show that Northcott and his mother are both insane.” It was reported, moreover, that Gordon told his jail keepers that “his boy friends” would “come to his rescue” and testify on his behalf leading to his acquittal. The idea was to find the 50 youths to counter this strategy.

Also notable was a report that Winnifred Clark, daughter and son of Louise and Gordon and mother of Jessie and Sanford, wrote to her daughter that she was sorry for “deserting her children,” while adding “I only hope that mother and brother can make their peace with God.” On hearing of this, Sanford remarked, “my mother knows I am telling the truth about Stewart killing the Collins boy and the Winslows. I hope she comes to Los Angeles and takes me back home to Canada with her after all this is over.” He was not expected to offer any further testimony prior to the trial.
As for that proceeding, Ford was to try both Northcotts for the murder of Walter Collins and “should the jury vote to hang . . . the remaining charges [involving the Winslows and the Latino teen] . . . will not be pressed,” but, if the death penalty was not imposed, “Ford will continue with the charges.” The paper ended by observing that the trial was anticipated to last up to a month and that trouble was likely with jury selection, “due to the widespread interest in the case expressed by Riverside county residents,” which is why there was prior talk of seeking a change in venue.

Under the headline of “Sister Turns on Northcott,” Kendrick of the Times, in its issue of the 4th, cited Winnifred Clark’s letter and specified her feelings of guilt in her remark “I don’t know why I deserted my own children in this terrible affair” after she “staunchly aided and defended” her mother and brother. As for Gordon’s claim of having new representation, he was quoted as saying “this thing is proceeding entirely too slow to suit me, and if necessary I’ll hire seven more lawyers,” after claiming he had an Angel City attorney retained to fight his extradition. His Canadian counsel Frank Lyons, though, told the press, “I don’t know where he can get the money to hire another barrister; in fact, I haven’t been paid yet.”
Observing that “prison life has turned Northcott from the arrogant and confident youth . . . three weeks ago, to a frenzied and at times dangerous prisoner,” the paper cited him as yelling at guards, “if I have to put up with another month of this thing I’ll go crazier than they accuse me of being.” As to his sister’s comments, Gordon remarked, “I should worry what my relatives do. I’ve go two boy friends in California who will walk into court and clear me in a minute.” What was unclear is whether his jailhouse remarks were calculated to prime his insanity defense, though it was added that “has lost much of the self-assurance” when he was apprehended.

In its report of the 4th, the Record offered an account involving an intended fifth victim of Gordon, with the paper stating,
This boy was said to have been held captive in the ranch house for several days, a victim of Northcott’s [sexual] abuse. He succeeded in escaping, it was said, and told Riverside officers of his experience when the murder charges were made against young Northcott. It was expected a full statement would be in the hands of Sheriff Clem Sweeters within 24 hours, adding new information to the ghastly evidence upon which Northcott was indicted by two counties.
A previous neighbor of the Wineville ranch, William H. Johnson, was said to have information “concerning Northcott’s treatment of his boy captives” and apparently “was forced to move away by the strange youth’s actions.” This was because “the cries of the boys reported to have been abused by Northcott unnerved him . . . and he abandoned his adjoining farm to get away from the Northcotts.” While Ford and Sweeters were confident they had enough evidence to send Gordon (and, presumably, Louise) to the noose, there was a find of two pairs of boys’ shoes near where some evidently human hair was recently found and testing was undertaken on these items.

William Bright, meanwhile, was said to have essentially completed his work in Los Angeles County “following the presentation of an ‘iron-clad’ case” regarding the killing of the unidentified youth found near the Homestead. At that grand jury hearing, the paper added, Sanford Clark “told of Northcott’s bringing ahead to the ranch one night in a bucket and making him help to burn it.” It was concluded that it took two hours for the hearing to be completed and, after an indictment was found, the district attorney’s office in the Angel City quickly prepared extradition papers to send to the governor.

We’ll return tomorrow with part three and more of the evolution of the extradition proceedings and preparations for trial, so be sure to check back with us then!