by Paul R. Spitzzeri
Having completed a November 1860 trip east and south from Los Angeles as far east as Yucaipa and south as Temescal near modern Corona and ended his sojourn with a visit with Nieves Rowland and John Reed at Rancho La Puente, a couple of miles east of the Homestead, John Quincy Adams Warren, a correspondent with the American Stock Journal, returned to Los Angeles and boarding at the Bella Union Hotel, where he composed “a few remarks upon [Los Angeles] county in general” for readers of the publication’s July 1861 edition.
Warren noted that “the largest source of water in the county,” until 1889 when Orange County was created, “is furnished from the Santa Ana River . . . where it is exhausted in its own bed before reaching the ocean,” this meaning that there was no flow directly to the Pacific in the dry fall season. He added that “the San Gabriel River has its source in the mountains near the boundary line between Los Angeles and San Bernardino County [sic],” though this is only partially true as, while the East Fork is in that area, there are northern and western forks, as well, “enters the plains about 20 miles northeast of the city and reaches the ocean about ten miles east of the port of San Pedro.”

Seven years later, flooding forced a new channel further east so that the Río Hondo comprises the old course, while the new river terminates at the former Anaheim Landing, where Seal Beach and Long Beach meet. The writer observed that “these rivers in their course afford a sufficient body of water, with proper management, to irrigate the vast and extensive plains on every side, rendering them fit for cultivation, whereas now they only furnish pasturage for stock.” As for land use, Warren remarked that “the whole county is well adapted for grazing; the rolling hills and table lands . . . produce perennial grasses, oats, clover, &c., of great excellence, while the plains produce but clover, alfilaria or pin grass in abundance, upon which the stock feed and fatten rapidly.
As he’d commented upon on several occasions, the writer lionized the “salubrious and unsurpassed” weather, adding that the mountain ranges to the north “form a barrier from the dry and inhospitable winds, from the arid regions of Utah and eastern frontier of California,” these, of course, being the Santa Ana winds, which, however, do occasionally wreak havoc. Without the buffer, it was asserted, these “would otherwise drink up all the moisture from the earth and destroy vegetation.” Moreover, “the climate and soil is [are] adapted to the growth and production of all varieties of fruit known, as well as those of the tropical regions which are here found growing side by side.”

Returning to irrigation, Warren noted that areas on which livestock grazed could, “by a little cost,” be “easily brought under cultivation and large crops obtained,” while some dry farming would also be successful—these being grains like barley and wheat. Foreseeing a future of intense water storage projects, the scribe commented that “by constructing reservoirs and artificial basins,” there could be plenty of water for lands from which “the now waste and useless tracts [could] be made to yield invaluable wealth to their owners and the county.” Artesian wells were in the early stages of development, though not at the depth needed to tap subterranean sources, especially in the swampy areas south of Los Angeles near the rudimentary port at San Pedro.
After thanking Juan José (Jonathan Trumbull) Warner, a resident since 1831 and a fount of knowledge about the region and observing that official records were lacking, Warren asserted that,
There is much need of the right kind of energy and activity in the stock-growing districts, and the causes of this apparent supineness I have given in former letters. This is much to be regretted, where such a large and fertile country offers such inducements and is so well adapted to stock growing on a different scale.
Specifically, this meant calling for a retrenchment on raising cattle in favor of goats and sheep and he observed that “the Cashmere goat would thrive admirably, and I am surprised that some one has not imported these valuable animals, for they would prove a fortune to some enterprising stock breeder.” Noting that they did well in the South, Warren inquired, “why not in California? Or Los Angeles?” and added “this subject needs attention.” With cattle prices declined significantly since the end of the Gold Rush a half decade prior, it was remarked that,
In spite of the drawbacks under which the county now labors, there is hope to believe that efforts will be made to a decided improvement in these several branches. Energy, capital and application will be sufficient to work wondrous changes in this county, and it will be done.
Suggestions were offered for a woolen factory (which was established in Los Angeles during its upcoming first boom in the 1870s) and a bottle plant. Next, Warren highlighted Abel Stearns, the wealthiest figure in Los Angeles and his dozen ranches in Los Angeles and San Bernardino counties, as well as Baja California, totaling 230,000 acres and on which he had 18,000 cattle and 3,000 horses—though his financial position would deteriorate during the next decade with a late lifeline as his properties were placed in a trust for sale. A chart of over 50 landowners and their ranches and acreage was followed by a list of 86,000 black cattle, 1,500 gentle (broken/tamed) horses and 7,500 wild ones and around 60,000 sheep.

For the year ending on 20 November, about the time Warren returned to the Angel City, the San Pedro shipping house of Tomlinson and Company reported nearly 1,200 bales and over 200,000 pounds of wool, north of 8,500 hides and 17 bales of sheep skins exported. In 1859, the wool clip was 824 bales and about 160,000 pounds, while cattle hides totaled nearly 7,000. There was another forwarding company, but the writer could not get the figures, though, as to the port, collector Patrick H. Downey (who happened to be the brother of Governor John G. Downey), reported that imports totaled about $195,000 for 1860 while exports were about $289,000.
Rudimentary as it was (and federal appropriations for a breakwater and dredging were about a decade away), the port was deemed “a good one and exposed only to the southeast winds, which renders it at times somewhat rough and dangerous,” while there were “several warehouses for the storage of goods, belonging to the forwarding houses” and the road to Los Angeles “a good and level one for most of the way” for the shipment of people and products. The local account then ended with,
In concluding, for the present, my notes of Los Angeles, I must acknowledge my warmest thanks for Dr. [Alvinza] Hayward, to F.P.F. Temple, [Los Angeles marshal] W[illiam] Warren, Dr. [Thomas J.] White, J.J. Warner, P. Downey, Wm. Workman, andother gentlement, for courtesies rendered me during my stay in the city, and to W. Warren, Esq., and F.P.F. Temple, Esq., for kindness in furnishing me with horses from their ranchos to enable me to obtain the information I desired through the county.
Warren intended to return “by request of many friends” to see more of Los Angeles County when its plains and valleys were clothed “during the season of fruits and flowers” following the rainy season “in their magnificent garbs of spring and summer.” This included a plan to see San Fernando “with its renowned groves of orange, lemon and olives,” and then go to Santa Barbara and points north, but, in the meantime, it was time to bid “‘adios’ to Los Angeles. A return to San Pedro on a Tomlinson stage led to boarding the steamship Senator for the voyage to San Francisco after six weeks away.

Before he left, Warren was mentioned twice in the Los Angeles News and Star, with the 30 November edition of the former thanking him for providing two pieces of sheet music and then the next day’s issue of the latter mentioning that three more pieces were made available—these suggesting that Warren did so because he was an agent for the San Francisco publisher. The San Francisco Alta California of 17 December recorded that the Senator arrived in San Francisco with Warren among its passengers The correspondent’s future letters for issues of the Journal from September 1861 through August 1862 concerned visits to Colusa, Marin, San Joaquin, Santa Clara and Tehama counties, as well as remarks on agricultural fairs and wool growing.
In its number of 17 July 1861, the Alta California published a short “NOTES OF RANCHOS IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY” based on Warren’s contribution to the Journal for its June edition, mentioning the Azusa and Santa Gertrudes ranchos, as well as short descriptions of F.P.F. Temple’s portion of La Merced and William Workman’s half of La Puente.

Following his return to San Francisco, Warren continued as an agent for the Journal, the American Bee Journal and for farming publications generally, including his advertising for works dealing specifically with horses. After serving as a deputy auditor for the city of Sacramento, he launched his own magazine, the California Wine and Wool Register, which was quickly renamed the California Wine, Wool and Stock Journal, of which the Homestead has four issues, from July to October 1863.
By spring 1864, Warren remarried and then was appointed a delegate of the California State Agricultural Society for Hawaii where he relocated in summer 1865, purportedly for health reasons. While there, he was an agent for the San Francisco American Flag newspaper and collected a wide variety of Hawaiian plants which he shipped to the California metropolis, to which he and his wife returned in June 1866, and exhibited some of these at that year’s California State Agricultural Fair. He also sent California and foreign plants to Hawaii in return as a corresponding member of the Royal Agricultural Society. A brief note during this period in the San Francisco Chronicle observed that Warren was considered a friend of the famed writer Mark Twain.

Warren remained in San Francisco until at least spring 1868, when he advertised in the Examiner for the sale of Japanese tea plant seeds, but, by the end of summer, he returned to Massachusetts after an absence of more than a decade. There, he exhibited at the state horticultural society, a large collection of California and Hawaiian plant materials, such as young trees, flowers, hard-grained wood samples, almonds, a broom made from the corn he mentioned in his letters from Los Angeles, sea gull eggs and stuffed animals, and was awarded a silver medal.
At the end of 1868, Warren, apparently divorced again, headed to Europe and settled in Paris, taking his collection with him. The Examiner of 2 April 1869 reported that “men of science of all countries” were intrigued with his specimens and were grateful for access to items they did not previously have available to them. The 26 June issue of the Los Angeles Star reprinted a letter from Warren, dated 1 May from the French capital and appraising a French resident of the Angel City that he was sending silk worms. Moreover, he expressed his love of California’s “unbounded success and pro[s]perity” and commented:
Her gold mines . . . are genuine and inexhaustible; but her agricultural wealth is the greatest wonder of the age. The great Pacific [Transcontinental] will soon cross the continent, and bring to you shores a large and beneficial population. Over the prairies of the West the iron horse is plunging on his way to the great country of the world; the two countries meet, the oceans shake hands together, and California lifts up her head for a benediction.
Just over a month later, however, the 31 July edition of the Star informed Angelenos that “during the recent riots in Paris,” a city often prone to these as recent events showed, “several Americans, who were spectators, paid the penalty of their indiscreetness by being arrested and hurried off to prison. Among those was J.Q.A. Warren.” He related that he was walking with a fellow expatriate when they heard drum beats and were nabbed by police agents and attacked.

At a prison, the account continued, his money and papers were seized, with only the latter restored, and Warren and hundreds of others, were marched to another jail with it recorded that “Mr. Warren was so badly bruised and hurt that he had to be supported by two of the prisoners” and his clothes were covered in his blood. Despite diplomatic involvement, Warren was sent to yet another location “where [he] suffered from the most exquisite tortures from hunger, thirst and filth” before he was finally released.
Some of this collection was saved and the 13 December number of the Sacramento Bee reported that he was given a silver medal at the Hamburg International Exhibition in Germany and a first prize gold medal at a fair in the Belgian city of Brussels. By summer 1870, the European sojourn was over and Warren was in New York City, where Warren spoke to a gathering of silk manufacturers about “details as to the prospect of silk culture on the Pacific coast and promoting native silk trade.”

The 16 November number of the Star told its readers, “we are not surprised to hear of ‘Professor’ J.Q.A. Warren turning up as a lecturer on the silk business” nor that he was endeavoring to secure federal support for the industry. The article added that the “Professor,” a frequently self-assigned honorific to impress others with a modicum of academic expertise, “is now traveling over the country” and speaking on the topic of a particular worm, though he was accused of bring “totally ignorant of what has been done in past years,” as it was stated that the type he advocated was not successfully cultivated.
Another move was made in 1871 as Warren settled in London, where he was a correspondent and representative of the Land and Water and it was reported by the Bee of 12 October that he shipped silkworms to an exposition in Cincinnati. He continued his promotion of the specified silk worm to agricultural organizations leading the Missouri state entomologist to warn in early 1873 “against the perverted and exaggerated statements which Mr. J.Q.A. Warren is in the habit of making, and which are calculated to do more harm than good.”

In November 1873, Warren wedded for the third time, but nothing substantive could be found about him until he was enumerated with his wife in the 1881 English census in the Marylebone section of London with his occupation given as “Literary Man.” Otherwise, the trail runs cold, though, when James died in 1896 at age 90, his obituary mentioned that he left four daughters and a son, and J.Q.A. was the only of the latter in the family. An intriguing reference from the 3 August 1900 edition of the newspaper in the California town of Calistoga in the Napa Valley north of San Francisco referred to “J.Q.A. Warren, a peddler,” who reported the theft of horses while he was camped along a creek, though it is not known if this was the same person.
Another notable late mention was in the Honolulu Star-Advertiser of 18 October 1921, which cited a letter from Mark Twain, in which he archly observed that he’d seen Warren soon after his return to the Golden State from Hawaii and remarked, “I made him famous in California with a paragraph which I need not have written unless I wanted to—and this is the thanks I get for it. He never would have been heard of it I had let him alone.” What Twain specifically meant was not searched for, but the association is certainly interesting.

J.Q.A. Warren’s visit to greater Los Angeles and his travels and descriptions of many persons and places, including the ranches of F.P.F. Temple and William Workman, in November 1860 are important in understanding the state of agriculture and livestock raising as the 1850s came to an end. With the Gold Rush long past, but the dire days of deluge and drought soon to come, as well as massive growth in subsequent decades, his account is of special interest, though it is significant that he did not visit any Californios and his prediction of the region’s dominance in grape growing and winemaking turned out to be wrong, while other forecasts were certainly valid. There is much to learn in his writings and Paul Gates should be thanked for bringing these letters to light six decades ago.