“Our Itching Palms Just Ache to MAKE Someone Guilty!”: The Wineville Chicken Coop Murderers Extradited, October 1928, Part Five

by Paul R. Spitzzeri

As the extradition process for accused child murderers Gordon Northcott and his mother Louise of the so-called Wineville Chicken Coop Murders, dragged on in early fall 1928 through protocols in California, Washington, D.C., and Ottawa, the capital of Canada, a third important witness in the forthcoming trial in Riverside County was nearly at that destination. Jessie Clark, nephew and granddaughter of the two, was transported through Los Angeles, the 10 October edition of that city’s Record reported, as she headed to Riverside in the company of a Lake Elsinore couple who agreed to be her guardian during her stay. Clark’s brother, Sanford, was an accomplice under duress while Cyrus Northcott, father and husband of the suspects, was also a key figure for the prosecution.

Riverside County criminologist J. Clark Sellers announced that a cap, with blood on it, located in a suitcase belonging to Gordon and found abandoned in a British Columbia cemetery was “to all legal intents” one belonging to a victim, Nelson Winslow, and that this identification meant that the county’s “chain of circumstantial evidence is complete.” Moreover, Sellers and Riverside city chemist Rex Welch traced the cap’s trademark to the store where the child’s mother told investigators she purchased it. Lastly, it was stated that Northcott was again released after an eight-day hold, as required by Canadian law regarding a lack of formal charges, but was, as before, rearrested as the extradition papers were awaited.

Los Angeles Record, 10 October 1928.

While the Los Angeles Express of the same day offered little in variance to that of its competitor, other than that Riverside County investigators were heading to Calgary for an extradition hearing for Louise, held there since her arrest, while Gordon was in a Vancouver jail, but headed back to the latter city upon receipt of a telegram, the contents of which were not disclosed, the Los Angeles Times added the notable information that Cyrus was readying a statement to Riverside County Sheriff Clem Sweeters concerning his spouse and son, but “has imposed certain conditions.” These were not publicized, but it was remarked that they were to be accepted and the remarks to come soon.

The following day’s Record observed that it was expected that the Northcotts would be extradited within a week, with the sheriff to head north and with his wife to be the escort for Louise. Despite this statement, however, the American consul at Calgary told investigators Bert Kelley and Jim Quinn that it would be around three weeks before the jaunt to Riverside could take place. As for Cyrus’ conference with Sweeters, the paper relayed that the elder Northcott told the sheriff he bought quicklime the day after Walter Collins was believed to have been killed at the Wineville ranch (the site now located in Jurupa Valley). Moreover, while Louise refused to speak to any Americans from her Calgary cell, claiming “they only intend to tell me a pack of lies about my darling son,” the police chief there remarked that “details of her story have differed every time she has told it.

Los Angeles Express, 10 October 1928.

When the Express reported on the expected extradition time, it cited the Calgary consul as stating that it would be a month, this according to Sweeters who “was frankly worried over the delay,” leading him to announce that he was traveling to Canada to take charge of matters for the prosecutors. There was also a report that Los Angeles Police Department detectives showed the sheriff the locations said to be the graves for Collins and the Winslow brothers, including Lewis.

James M. Kendrick, the Times representative in reporting from Canada, filed a report for the paper’s edition of the 11th, informed readers that the extradition papers were again delayed as they were on their way, but not received by the Department of State, at Washington. This, of course, was compounded by the 20-day timeframe regarding extradition after a court hearing. It was reiterated that Louise, who freely talked to Canadian officers even though rules banned questioning, would not speak to any California investigators or reporters until she was back in Riverside, as she asserted:

All they are trying to do is to get me and my darling boy to make different statements so they can trip us up and make liars out of us . . . There is a frame-up against us in California and we could never get a fair hearing there.

A separate report from Vancouver indicated that a hearing was scheduled for Gordon in a week, after the mandated eight-day appearance included the observation that the accused entered the courtroom “head erect and with a somewhat grim smile upon his lips” as Northcott “joked and laughed with his attorney and the provincial constable.” He was quoted as insisting that the charges were based on “politics,” while declaring “I hope Jessie Calrk [sic] gets all the notoriety out of this that she wants.” It was added that the Northcotts were allowed to send letters to each other, but were prohibited from discussing the case. A third short news item stated that the governor’s office in Sacramento was informed that the State Department sent the extradition papers to Canada the prior day.

Los Angeles Times, 10 October 1928.

In its number of the 12th, the Record recorded that Sanford Clark was questioned again about the details of the Wineville murders and an affidavit prepared and sent to Vancouver to be filed with the court in advance of Gordon’s extradition hearing. It was noted that this was done to counter any attempts by the Northcotts to mount an insanity defense to fight their being sent south. The paper added that, while local investigations were concluded, efforts were still undertaken in Vancouver to find three suitcases said to have been abandoned by Gordon.

Additionally, the whereabouts of Jessie Clark were confused, so that it was thought she and her escorts were still north of San Francisco. Lastly, Sweeters told the press that he expected that Gordon and Louise, who was to be taken first to Seattle, would travel on the same train, but segregated, as they headed to California and that they might stop in Los Angeles for questioning concerning “the headless murder at Puente,” meaning the Latino (or Filipino) teen, whose body was found at the edge of or adjacent to the Homestead, then owned by Walter P. Temple.

Record, 12 October 1928.

The Express of the same day reported that a separate extradition request from Los Angeles County, in the matter of the Puente killing, was approved by the governor and these to be sent to Washington and Ottawa as with the Riverside County requests—this being a back-up in case of a failure of the latter’s prosecution. Relatedly, it was stated that Riverside officials told Capt. William Bright of the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department that he could interview Jessie Clark about the young Latino’s killing.

Separately the paper noted that the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU), which advocated for abstention from alcohol, but also took on other causes, petitioned the Los Angeles City Council for the firing of Capt. Joseph J. Jones of the police department’s juvenile bureau because of his detaining Christine Collins, mother of Walter, in the county hospital psychopathic ward after she resisted accepting a runaway that Jones insisted was her son, though it was later proven he was not. It was added that “many women other than members of the W.C.T.U. have demanded drastic action, which so far has not materialized.”

Express, 12 October 1928.

The reporting of the Times for the 12th was that Sweeters and his wife left Riverside the evening before for Calgary so they could retrieve Louise, as it was anticipated that extradition proceedings would be finished on the 13th and Canadian officials “prepared to turn over the prisoner on short notice and without delay.” The idea, as noted above, was to transport her to Seattle and jailed until the hearings were completed for Gordon, with Kelley and Quinn taking him in charge, and the two brought back on the same train, on which they could see one another, but not travel jointly.

In its number of the 13th, the Record related that Kelley and Quinn went to the Calgary court with extradition papers signed by California and federal officials to seek custody of Louise and they hoped to get her Canadian barrister to agree not to appeal if she was ordered to be sent south. It was added that it would take three days to send a signed judicial order to Ottawa and pave the way for Louise’s return, while the paper observed that “she continued to pace her cell . . . and carry on in unintelligible rumblings.”

Times, 13 October 1928.

While Sweeters was recently in San Diego seeking a connection to the death of a 13-year-old boy there, his deputy, Ben de Crevecoeur, was looking into a 14-year-old boy who vanished in the spring from Glen Avon, north of Riverside to determine if there was a tie to the Northcotts, as well. The deputy, according to the Express, was also intent on “breaking” Cyrus through further interrogation, as it was insisted that he “has held back on many important facts” as well as the matter of the Glen Avon youth’s disappearance with it added that the youngster knew Cyrus and Gordon.

The Times of that day published a photo of Louise walking with a jail matron and police official into a Calgary courtroom, while Kendrick noted that Kelley and Quinn finished meeting with the barrister representing Riverside County, the latter apparently feeling “satisfied with the evidence brought here by California officers and declared his belief that there is no question but that Mrs. Northcott’s extradition will be ordered.” The investigators, meanwhile, were reported to have been surprised that Sweeters was heading to Calgary, apparently feeling he should wait until it was definitively established that the order was completed. As for Louise’s Canadian counsel, J. McKinley Cameron “indicated that he is not satisfied with ‘proofs'” from her grandson Sanford that she was involved in Walter Collins’ murder.

Express, 13 October 1928.

A Kendrick report published on the 14th included the possibility that an evidentiary hearing might be held in Calgary before the extradition papers reached the Alberta city, this evidently was requested by Cameron who cited “ugly press reports” among reasons to expedite the proceeding. Kelley and Quinn, though, asked for more time to review those papers. When the duo met Louise in person for the first time, “she refused to discuss her case with them” and when Quinn offered to let her have an hour with Gordon if she voluntarily went with them to Vancouver, this was rebuffed. Lastly, she wanted Cameron to represent her son, too, but Gordon preferred his barrister, Frank Lyons.

The Times representative, in the edition of the 15th, shared a noticeable rupture in Louise’s claims that she never went to the Northcott ranch at Wineville when investigators sprung a trap when they told her that a turtle from the property was given by Cyrus to friends and then asked about a former police dog of hers. It was reported that she replied that the turtle was “the last one of sixty that Stewart and I had at the ranch,” while, with regard to the canine, she stated, “I took the police dog from the ranch to our Brittania-street home in Los Angeles and traded it for a radio.” After she realized she’d fallen for the ruse, she “went into a rage when she realized the value to the officers of her statement.”

Times, 14 October 1928.

Livid from the interview, Louise summoned the jail matron “and declared that under no circumstances will she again chat with the Riverside officers,” as she railed against them as well as chided her son about where money were to be had for their legal expenses:

They want me to do something against my will. I am innocent of the charges, but when I get down there [to California] they will railroad me . . . One thin Gordon should remember is the Riverside county chicken farm is in mine and Mr. Northcott’s names and it will be up to us to provide the defense funds.

Other news included a report that an unidentified Los Angeles law firm was to take charge of Louise’s defense and that her first contact with Cyrus, in the form of a letter, was mailed to him the prior evening, though the contents of the missive, known to authorities, were not revealed to the press. A notable rumor was that famed attorney Clarence Darrow was to represent mother and son, though Gordon asserted that Lyons would represent him and his mother, while claiming he had many offers from prominent American attorneys to defend him gratis. A telegram he sent to Louise was reprinted definitively stating that Lyons was his counsel and urging she do so, as well.

Record, 15 October 1928.

The Record of the same day basically presented the same information as its contemporary, though it added that barrister Cameron told Kelley and Quinn that he would not waive the right to appeal an extradition ruling for Louise. A brief article in the Express related how Louise, “hurling her defiance” at local officials, told the press at Calgary that she would fight extradition “to the last ditch” because they were “attempting to railroad her to the gallows” and spat out that “they’ll put over none of their high-pressure measures on me.” Lastly, she claimed that there was “plenty of money” for legal expenses, even as the only income was her work as a launderer and Cyrus’ work in carpentry—though the ranch was obviously of greater value.

The 16th brought a report from the Record that Kelley and Quinn headed out to Saskatchewan to seek more evidence, this likely those trio of missing pieces of luggage, while it was stated that Cameron decided not to pursue an appear after all if a judge ordered extradition, although “he was not convinced Quinn and Kelly [sic] could prove Mrs. Northcott was on the murder ranch at the time that asserted ax-slayings too place.” The papers received from Ottawa were signed by the United States consul and a hearing expected soon on the matter of remanding Louise to Riverside County authorities.

Express, 15 October 1928.

In the next day’s Times another disappearance was investigated with purported links to the Northcotts, this concerning a 14-year-old boy who vanished from El Centro, east of San Diego, as he was returning to the Los Angeles military school he attended. A gas station owner sent his foster parents a suitcase and letter, with the former said to contain clothes of Walter Collins, while the latter, purportedly written from Oregon and claimed the teen was working there, “resembles the writing of Mrs. Sarah Louise Northcott.” Moreover, laundry marks on clothing were said to be like those on articles of Northcott clothing.

Kendrick reported from Calgary that Sweeters told him that “the boy [Gordon] and his mother are practically broke,” this determined after Gordon bragging about “unlimited financial resources” and insistence that he could hire seven lawyers to represented him, if he wanted. Cameron told Kelley and Quinn that the only remuneration he received for representing Louise was $400 raised by friends of her daughter Winnifred, mother of Sanford and Jessie. There was also a report from Sweeters that Ernest Baker, a Highland Park man previously mentioned here with respect to his reported illicit intimacy with boys, was likely to be arrested based on letters found at the Wineville ranch.

Times, 17 October 1928.

Lastly, in his “Shootin’ Straight” column in the Express, also of the 17th, Alexander Y. Tully, who previously had pointed words about the way the investigations and extradition processes were carried out and having castigated the carrying of Jessie Clark over the border due to the idea that local authorities were concerned that any testimony in a Canadian proceeding “might assist the accused to prove innocence,” offered this pungent prose:

the Riverside police, finding it impossible to “spirit” [Gordon] Northcott from under the nose of Canadian justice, are twiddling their thumbs in the anteroom [of the courthouse] while the Canadians decide whether a few chicken feathers and chicken-coop blood stains constitute sufficient foundation upon which to lay a murder charge.

The purpose of the Canadian courts, it seems, is to find out whether the accused is innocent or guilty; our itching palms just ache to MAKE someone guilty!

Next, we’ll continue our coverage of October media reports, so be sure to check back with us for part six!

Leave a Reply