“The Whole Population of California Has Adopted Its Usual Madness of Manufacturing Evidence”: The Wineville Chicken Coop Murderers Extradited, October 1928, Part Six

by Paul R. Spitzzeri

As the saga involving the extradition from Canada of wanted alleged mother-and-son child killers Gordon and Louise Northcott dragged on into late October 1928 in the so-called Wineville Chicken Coop Murders case, some definitive news on this front was finally reported in the Los Angeles Record of the 20th, which recorded,

Following a rapid turn of events . . . Mrs. Louise Northcott . . . was under orders today to return to California with Riverside county officers.

This extradition order came as a surprise, as her hearing had previously been delayed . . . pending the correction of extradition papers.

County investigators Bert Kelley and Jim Quinn presented evidence, some ruled as hearsay, to a Calgary jurist, who then released her into their custody as he “declared the Riverside officers had proved a prima facie [sufficient proof] case of murder against the woman.” It was added, though, that Louise had 15 days after the order before she could be escorted back to California.

Los Angeles Times, 18 October 1928.

As for Gordon, he apparently took the news with no expression of surprise, although it was reported that “he paced his cell nervously . . . and declared a la comedian Oliver Hardy: ‘It is a shame poor little mother must suffer all this embarrassment” as his nephew and niece (and her grandchildren) “Sanford and Jessie [Clark] certainly have got us into a fine mess.” Kelley and Quinn, their work done in Calgary, immediately headed to Vancouver to prepare for Gordon’s hearing. Lastly, Jessie Clark, taken from Canada to Riverside, “yesterday gave full information of the Wineville ‘murder farm’ to District Attorney Albert Ford.”

Jessie’s arrival in Riverside was marked by the Los Angeles Express, in its edition of the 18th, with the observation that she “was kept in hiding” and was “to be assured a complete rest after the months of terror she says she has spent, as a result of her discoveries.” There was some concern in the paper’s prior day edition that the Northcotts “may never be returned here for trial” because, a Canadian barrister representing the American federal government in the extradition process against Gordon told the press that “Riverside county officials, who have handled the case against Northcott, have bungled it completely.”

Los Angeles Express, 19 October 1928.

Specifically, opined Royal L. Maitland, previously the Vancouver city prosecutor and future Canada Bar Association president and British Columbia attorney general, Ford “had made so many mistakes that it was necessary for him to return all the papers to [the United States] for correction” and it was added that this was the second time this was so done. It was expected that another month would be taken up with delays, if any further progress was at all possible.

The paper continued that “the bungling of the case has already cost Riverside taxpayers more money than any previous criminal action held in that county” and $3,000 appropriated by the board of supervisors was gone, including lawyers’ fees and the expenses of the investigators and Sheriff Clem Sweeters and his wife while they were in Canada. The situation was said to be such that,

The delays occasioned by the bungling of the case . . . have caused resentment by Canadian citizens as well as officials. As a result the public feeling toward Northcott and his mother has entirely changed. Both are in receipt of scores of letters from Canadians protesting against their further detention.

Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Captain William Bright was also chagrined by this as he offered to have his county’s Deputy District Attorney Roscoe Denny, an acknowledged foreign extradition expert, assist, but Ford resisted. The back-up plan, however, was for Los Angeles County officials to take up the case of the killing of an unidentified Latino (or Filipino) youth, whose headless body was found on Hudson Road (Hacienda Boulevard) at the edge of or adjacent to the Homestead, then owned by Walter P. Temple. An indictment and extradition papers were already prepared and ready for this contingency, in case the Riverside County case collapsed under the weight of the asserted incompetence.

Los Angeles Record, 20 October 1928.

In its number of the 20th, the Express addressed the ongoing issue involving one of the victims, Walter Collins, whose mother was allegedly forced by a Los Angeles Police Department juvenile department captain, Joseph J. Jones, to take a runaway reputed to be her son. Even after she informed him that the boy was not her child, Christine Collins asserted that Jones assailed her and had her committed in the psychiatric ward of the county hospital.

Because of insinuations that there were parties trying to pressure Collins into dropping her charges against Jones, the official told the press that she would be kept in hiding, even as the Rev. Gustav Briegleb, who took up her cause, planned a mass meeting at his Trinity Methodist Church. The pastor proclaimed “this city is up in arms and means to flood this disgraceful miscarriage of justice with the light of day” and he called for all Angel City mothers to support the effort to punish Jones for his misdeeds.

Times, 20 October 1928.

Meanwhile, Collins filed a damage suit against Jones and Police Chief James E. Davis for false imprisonment and sought a half million dollars in damages, while she was said to be readying two more suits on the grounds of libel and slander involving a million dollars in damages. There were also reports that the City Council would conduct a hearing on the matter and women’s groups were prepared to take part and decry the “maladministration of the police department.” This was in addition to other concerns about the LAPD and corruption under the leadership of Chief Davis.

In its coverage of the 18th, the Los Angeles Times devoted a fair amount of space to Jessie Clark’s arrival in Riverside, including her immediate meeting with a former Riverside County district attorney, Loyal C. Kelley, hired as her counsel and who told the media that his client would stay under wraps until after her uncle and grandmother were brought to Riverside for trial. There was, however, a brief encounter with reporters at which Jessie said “she would have further revelations to make on the strange case before trial” and assist Sanford and local officials “in substantiating the charges.” As to the rift among the Northcotts about their legal representation, Gordon insisted that, if his existing barrister, Frank Lyons, was not retained, he would defend himself instead.

Times, 20 October 1928.

In its number two days later, the Times reported that, following the extradition hearing, Louise was bundled off to a remote Saskatchewan prison, some 500 miles northeast of Calgary, for the 15-day period, despite her avowed intention to forego an appeal, before she could be take to California. All she said publicly was that she was glad for “a change of homes,” while Gordon expressed dismay, telling his barrister, “it seems to me that there is some better place . . . to take my poor mother,” while he addressed the appeal issue thusly:

All this talk about her waiving her right of appeal is tommyrot. She certainly will appeal the decision and I know she will get it reversed. We are not going to be taken back there [to California] and railroaded to the penitentiary just because my nephew and niece are suffering hallucinations.

Separately in the issue, the paper covered the Christine Collins lawsuit and observed that the Police Commission recently exonerated Jones of any wrongdoing in the matter because Arthur Hutchins, Jr., the runaway posting as Walter, “so completely fooled neighbors and old friends of the Collins family” that the captain could not be held responsible for wrongdoing.

Record, 22 October 1928.

This decision aroused such public antipathy, however, that three commissioners went to Mayor George E. Cryer complaining of incessant calls and even threat, while the public welfare committee of the City Council was to hold a public hearing to decide whether the larger body should request Cryer to reopen the matter. The chief executive also met with Collins’ counsel about the situation, but nothing was decided about how the mayor would act.

In its number of the 21st, the Times noted that the Clark siblings were to reunite for the first time since Jessie abruptly left Los Angeles to return home to Canada, where she first told what she know of the horrors at Wineville. After the reunion, Jessie was to hold her first media interview since her return to the region, while a summary of her meeting with D.A. Ford was to be made public.

Express, 22 October 1928.

The Record of the 22nd informed readers that a meeting between Ford and his Los Angeles County counterpart, Asa Keyes, was to determine whether Gordon would be tried first in Los Angeles County and Riverside County based on “whether the strongest evidence to substantiate the amazing stories . . . lies in” one or the other. If it was determined that the evidence was stronger for the Puente murder than those committed at Wineville, then Los Angeles would leapfrog Riverside. In any case, both men pledged assistance to the other.

In another of his “Shootin’ Straight” columns for the Express, this also on the 22nd, Alexander Y. Tully returned to the “mania for a conviction,” as well as “the utter disregard for the rights of the ‘the accused,” as he asserted that these problems “constitute the most serious weaknesses of the American police system.” Tully cited remarks from a colleague in Vancouver, who assailed the move to spirit Jessie over the border into the U.S. as “a tremendous piece of impertinence” concerning the jurisdictional responsibilities of the Canadian courts in the extradition process.

Express, 23 October 1928.

The journalist, James Butterfield, asked, “how do we know that Northcott ever committed a single murder?” and then offered that,

Since the first suggestion that he had done so the whole population of California has adopted its usual madness of manufacturing evidence out of every stick, stone or feather found upon his ranch.

Asserting that Canadian courts were obligated to assure that there was enough evidence to extradition, Butterfield castigated Riverside County investigators for taking Jessie out of the country when she was a material witness for proceedings and opined that “the administration of extradition courts is in a poor way” under such circumstances. Jessie, as a Canadian citizen, should have been examined, not only for veracity but “for sanity, or general reliability in her mental reactions.”

Record, 23 October 1928.

After remarking that Americans would widely agree with Canadian methods and standards, though some of the police in the latter seemed to have forgotten their duties and were “spurred on by the hope of publicity,” while pursuing the matter “regardless of international courtesy or of rights, whether or human or divine,” the Canadian columnist concluded that the Northcott case was,

An example of police practices well worthy of investigation by the Bar Association in the case of Mrs. Collins. Put a clothespin on your nose and dig into that one!

When the Express reported in its edition of the 23rd on the results of the confab between Ford and Keyes, it noted that the Northcotts were to be tried first in Los Angeles County in the matter of the Latino youth found dead near the Homestead. In an apparent effort to bolster their case, Riverside County authorities announced newly discovered evidence with regard to the murder of Walter Collins, but no details were forthcoming, though it was posited that this would “cinch Ford’s case against the Northcotts.”

Times, 23 October 1928.

The Times of the same day, however, informed its readership that a first trial against Gordon “may take place in Los Angeles county,” though deputy district attorney Clifford Thoms remarked that, while he was not aware of all the evidence gathered in the Wineville killings, “we have a certain conviction against Northcott for the death of the youth near Puente.”

Therefore, the Los Angeles officials were prepared to “assume the work of prosecuting the case” and, if it was agreed that the first trial would be held in the Angel City, they “will assume the work of prosecuting the case and will immediately move to return [Gordon] Northcott here under extradition proceedings started following his indictment.” Yet, the paper concluded, there was no definitely decision made with the matter.

Express, 24 October 1928.

The following day’s paper followed what the Express reported by commenting that Gordon was to be tried in Los Angeles before Riverside because the evidence in the Puente killing “was more conclusive.” The Times also seemed to believe that the youth killed at the Northcott house in the Angel City was a Filipino, though it hastened to add that “positive identification has been been established.”

Whereas the order to send Louise back to California was recently made, it was stated that Gordon and his counsel, Lyons, intended to keep the right to appeal an extradition order and Canadian law regarding the length of an appeal application, as well as a stay of execution, could well delay Gordon’s removal to this region by more than a month.

Record, 24 October 1928.

As for Jessie’s interview with reporters, which she seems to have done begrudgingly because of Gordon’s accusation that she was seeking notoriety and publicity, following her meeting with Sanford, she stated that their mother, Winnifred, sold furniture and personal items to provide $400 to Louise’s barrister, Cameron.” She repeated that her grandfather Cyrus “was aware that ‘evidence’ at the farm was being destroyed” in early August and that he told her that he was asked by his wife and son to help them in dealing with bodies, but he refused, telling them, “I won’t get mixed up in this mess.” She also was indignant about Canadian criticism about how she left her home country to head south to assist in the trial testimony against her kin.

In its account of the 24th, the Record ran a headline of “Niece of Northcott Bares New Evidence” in her comments to Riverside officials, but was warned not to reveal details, obviously because of concerns of prejudicing the case. Otherwise, the reporting by the paper essentially echoed that of the prior day.

Times, 24 October 1928.

That day’s Express featured remarks from Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney Thomas Menzies that a thorough investigation from police and sheriff investigators meant “a perfect hanging case around Northcott,” while it was added that he would “conduct his prosecution around scientific lines. The paper concluded that, if Gordon was convicted for the Puente murder, there would be no trial on the killings of Walter Collins and the Winslow brothers, but that Louise would be tried in the Collins murder regardless.

With this, we’ll halt for the time being and return with a part seven, so be sure to check back for that!

Leave a Reply